Today's view from the ground: New York, NY
If a person is affected at all by a place like Haiti, the return from it can be shocking. To have such a place so close to the United States (less than four hours' flight from New York and barely 80 minutes from Miami) is a distinction that illicits morbid curiosity. It is the only nation in the Caribbean that still rests on the edge of the naked past. It is also the only one that seems devoid of the English grandiosity, the Spanish zeal, or even the French stateliness that peppered other central American countries, as its early independence gave it new growth which continues away from the others. So it is the only such place where Americans can be enjoying their usual dinner directly after a morning of treating disease that should be extinct.
Haiti is continously speaking. The land and the people tell me new honorable and horrible stories that defy imagination every time I land and take off again. I have spent more time and certainly logged more visits to Haiti than most of the places I have been and, although I can lay claim to some expertise in limited fields, the place as a whole seems to slip farther away from my comprehension with each departure. It is a good idea, then, to wait to pass any sort of judgement on my experience until a few days after I have felt the arms of loved ones around me, clean food and water slip back into the commonplace, and the breathtaking sunsets of the Haitian hinterland have been replaced by the soft glowing chandelier atop the gorgeous Theater One of the Village East Cinema on Second Avenue.
I understand a few more things about Haiti and the struggles we all endure there, and many of these lessons are applicable to more than just that country or the plight of humanitarian aid. The reading several may find some help and hope in what came out of this remarkable journey.
There are many people to thank for this experience, although I know of some of them would prefer to remain anonymous (for reasons that will become clearer later). Danny McAtee's Haiti Medical Aid Project at dannymcateeinhaiti.com has long been the premier destination for dirty-boots coverage of the Haitian health care experience, and his Facebook group of the same name has become a Thorn-Tree-style bulletin board for getting and giving help in the best and worst of circumstances. Notable mentions of other writing and photography of this and other Haitian ventures will be forthcoming, once I can identify them and figure out if people want them listed.
1) You never own money. Money owns you.
It is generally a rule in life that the person who has the most also has the most to lose. Haiti is a place where that is especially true. History has shown that the people who ran the country, far from being immune to loss, were often targeted for dispossession and death. Anyone who currently has wealth to speak of must guard it very well, with walls and gates and broken bottles set in cement on top of them. On top of being unsightly, all of this protection is quite expensive. We often feel ridiculous to be spending large amounts of money on food, water, transport, and security in a place where many people are homeless and subsist on less than US$2 a day.
In January 2011, we were responsible for a base of operations (behind a wall and a gate), a broken-down van that caused more problems than it solved, and large quantities of food and water. By Haitian standards, we were very well-off - and spending astronomical amounts on all of it. In March 2011, we ate street food, rode tap-taps around the city, slept on stretchers and roofs, and we got ten times more done. The safety that all our earlier responsibilities assured us of was destroyed in a moment of violence that money could not guard from, and then we were free.
We made money, but not more than we needed. Once we were as poor as the people we worked with, or at least lived like it, the jangling choruses of children asking us for a dollar dulled out and vanished. None of the people I worked with are anti-capitalist; in fact, most of us seem to spend a lot of time figuring out where more money will be coming from. But money cannot always get you where you need to go. Money often picks its own path for you. There are too many people on that path who do not realize it, and there are too many people joining them.
2) Grant yourself the serenity.
Most people make lists of things they should carry. Mine is very short and consists mostly of multi-purpose objects that don't take up much space (the theft of my belay cord, hoisting winch, and equipment rack when it was serving as my clothesline in Joli Guibert was an unfortunate loss). However, above the need to carry adaptable objects, we must become adaptable objects.
Well before I ever studied medicine, I asked a doctor what stress is. She told me that it's a physical reaction to some pressure on ourselves that constricts our body systems and, if it persists, damages them. When I asked a rabbi the same question, his answer was not dissimilar. Essentially, stress is our reaction to conflict, competition, unreasonable demands - all the things not going our way. As someone used to nag me when I was upset, "in a fight between you and the world, bet on the world." Thank you, Franz Kafka, for coming up with the best way to get my goat. But the man was right. In most stress-inducing situations, the only way to keep our bodies from shredding themselves is to not pick a fight.
On this trip to Haiti, as well as many others and in different places, I have worked with people who end up frustrated and frenzied into a righteous rage. This type of anger is usually what institutes change over time when it is properly channeled. But in the moment, when nothing meaningful can change, the calmer among us rightly dissuade the others from such pique. Pique makes for excellent drama (another inflated currency among those who embark on this lifestyle, even for a week at a time) but little else except disillusionment, depression, and stress. The best difference between people who take despair and people who take wisdom from these places is that the latter do not crash into an oncoming system. They understand and accept the system, whether or not they agree with it or work inside it. The debate between religions teaches us that ideology and principles are the same thing viewed in a negative and positive light, respectively. Positive lights may shine false, but it saves our energy for the time to pick a fight we can win.
3) Keep your name to yourself.
Haiti is a place powered by voices. It is the cacophonous cry of ordinary people that has shaken its tree of liberty countless times, bringing rotten apples falling to earth. Whispers such as "ssst" and exclamations like "aba!" command Haitians' attention more than billboards and slogans. Kreyol, the Haitian language, suffers an awkward relationship with letters and spelling because it is a "spoken language" and has a written form because others demand it. In such a place, you are not your Facebook profile and you are not the letters after your name. You are what is said of you.
In most respects, this is a strength. The more permanent blans in Haiti that work on various development projects have good reputations that have been well-earned by fair treatment of many people, all of whom speak about them. The best way to find something or someone is to ask someone else, making relationships in Haiti feel more real than the ones that feed on computers and cell phones. Unfortunately, there is little of the evidence that the modern age has come to rely on about people; in my dumber time in Haiti, I shouted "give me names" in regard to a character accusation, which was (unlike the accusation) recorded. So it is also easy to be ill-defined as a dilettante, a braggart, and a fool.
Some of the pseudonyms used in THHL are used at the request of the people they refer to, as a name is a difficult thing to protect in such a vocal environment. But the lesson of self-imposed anonymity applies to more than a name and to a larger place than Haiti. The best reason people have for keeping to themselves is to counter the reaction to jump on board with every idea that sounds good but, as is often the case in Haiti, fails to stand up to reality. People are willing to help, but lies that say one is a fool are not as bad as truths that say one is a fool.
All of the projects I have been lucky enough to work on have been fueled by the thoughts and labors of the unknown and nameless, either by design or by chance. It is fitting that Haiti's grandest monument to its history is the Marron, the nameless slave who liberated himself and his people by sounding a horn made of conch. Those who demand their names shine on the pediment of their accomplishments are often unwise, and those who demand to be left alone to do their work are often the most trusted men and women of Haiti and elsewhere.
4) Find a line between the shadows and the sun.
When I was growing up, it seemed that there was no greater aspiration than to live in a massive empty house on a tiny piece of land and drive a fancy bright-colored car. In the generation before mine, the ideal was an expansive Tuscan-inspired estate with the first initial of a family's last name pressed on the gates to give the image of permanence. Both are versions of braggadocio that don't often go over well, especially in places like Haiti (see Point 1).
People seeing someone being useful is always a good thing. It inspires respect, the lubricant of all human interactions, and encourages further usefulness among others. It is, however, very easy to have this usefulness misunderstood. One of the issues I had when I began working in humanitarian fields on my own (without the flag of the U.N. or some other organization over me) was how to identify myself. I had long since faced the fact that I "glow in the dark" in Asia, Africa, and most parts of the Americas. I obviously don't belong. So I went whole-hog and made myself look like what I am: a medic. The problem was that medics look different all over the world. Most of the uniforms selected for medic duty, with their tough fabrics and multiple pockets, look like military uniforms; the police in Haiti and the dreaded army before them wore the same types and colors of pants and boots that most U.S. medics wear, leading to confusion and fear among Haitians when they encountered large numbers of uniformed aid workers in 2010. The loss of insignia makes it all the more strange. In most cases now, I wear a T-shirt and jeans with a practical khaki shirt emblazoned with a red cross, the universal symbol of medical care.
This leads to its own problems. I am now easy to pick out for help, and there are many situations in which I cannot help (when there are too many patients, when my own safety is in danger, etc.). But my intentions and role in places where I don't belong become clear. One of my most trusted and least identifiable colleagues travels around Port-au-Prince with no medical insignia other than a stethoscope around his neck, an idea I then adopted later in my trip. But the lesson was clear: there is a big difference between showing and showiness, a difference that can lead to theft, injury, and death when it is mishandled. All over the world, humility and self-restraint are respected values, if not honored practices, and one can luxuriate in the sun and take cover in the shadows when one has come to peace with the surroundings and the surroundings have dictated their allowance for a person.
5) Stethoscope tanlines.
They look bad-ass for a day or two, but then they just look like you were pulling a plow. Try to avoid them.
That's the view from the ground.
